Groundbreaking research uncovers sex-based differences in anesthetic sensitivity, suggesting that women may require different anesthetic management from men due to a resistance influenced by hormonal factors like testosterone.
A recent study titled “Hormonal basis of sex differences in anesthetic sensitivity” has advanced our understanding of how anesthetics might work slightly differently in male and female animals. According to corresponding author, Dr. Max Kelz from University of Pennsylvania, “This research is clinically important, as it sheds light on why women might respond differently to general anesthesia compared to men. Notably, this has not previously been recognized in anesthetic practice, and there is currently no recommendation to administer anesthesia differently for people based on their biological sex.”
The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences and delves into the world of general anesthesia – a state of induced unconsciousness allowing for pain-free surgeries. Anesthetics are thought to work in part by affecting brain regions that control sleep and wakefulness. Interestingly, these regions differ between males and females due to the influence of sex hormones like testosterone.
The research team undertook a comprehensive investigation to interpret these gender-specific reactions, conducting mouse experiments and analyzing human data, which led to some revelatory insights.
- Female Resistance to the hypnotic effects of anesthetics: One of the discoveries was that female brains, both in mice and humans, show a higher resistance to the effects of volatile anesthetics. This suggests women might need different anesthetic management compared to men.
- The role of testosterone: The study found that testosterone, traditionally considered a male hormone, might play a key role in how anesthetics work. Lower concentrations of testosterone, as seen in females, appear to contribute to resistance to general anesthesia.
- Beyond EEG readings: An interesting aspect of the study was that conventional electroencephalogram (EEG) methods, used to measure brain activity during anesthesia, couldn’t detect these sex-based differences. This suggests that standard practices might not fully capture how anesthetics affect men and women differently.
The collaborative research effort, led by Max Kelz, MD, PhD, Alex Proekt, MD, PhD, Andrzej Z. Wasilczuk, PhD, Cole Rinehart, MD, Adeeti Aggarwal, MD, PhD, and Martha E. Stone, MS, from the University of Pennsylvania’s Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care, in conjunction with George A. Mashour, MD, PhD, from the University of Michigan Medical School’s Department of Anesthesiology, and Michael S. Avidan, MBBCh, from the Washington University School of Medicine’s Department of Anesthesiology, represents a comprehensive approach to tackling this complex issue.
“This research is groundbreaking in several respects, including the fundamental lesson that scientists must be open to challenging existing paradigms and perceptions,” said Mashour. “We have been administering general anesthesia to hundreds of millions of people around the world for over 175 years, and yet we are only now discovering that men and women might respond differently to the potent hypnotic actions of general anesthetic agents.”
Avidan emphasized the significance of these findings, stating, “This research is both interesting and provocative as it guides us towards personalized anesthesia care. Understanding that there might be clinically meaningful different responses to general anesthetics between men and women has the potential to enhance safety and comfort. Specifically, the translation of these findings into clinical practice could decrease the occurrence of traumatic intraoperative awareness.”
This research suggests the need to develop more targeted and individualized anesthesia protocols, potentially leading to improved outcomes for patients undergoing surgery.